I love this thread!
I don't think Legolas should be a cat! For one thing, cat's think they own the world and everyone should bow down to them. They are also cruel and sneaky, despite how cute they are. Legolas is not like that at all!
Wormtongue is definitely a snake; just ask Gandalf!
I think Eowyn is a palomino (spelling?). Though that sounds strange, it doesn't if you look at them.
Frodo is a rabbit, of course!
How could any of them be a panther, except maybe Lurtz?! Panthers are cruel, and ruthless, and they would tear someone to peices without even thinking about it! Somehow that just doesn't remind me of Aragorn, but...to everyone their own opinions...
I think Gollum is a fox, foxes are sneaky...
I can't really think of Arwen as ANY animal, except maybe a butterfly. They look pretty and graceful all the time and don't bother anyone but just drink nectar.
And Pippin is a koala! How cute!
