Arwen-Undomiel.com
http://arwen-undomiel.com/forum/

Best Character Elimination Round 12
http://arwen-undomiel.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=15&t=22672		 Page 1 of 55
Author:  Seren [ May 8th, 2013, 9:05 pm ]
Post subject:  Best Character Elimination Round 12
Same rules as the previous few threads: you can only vote once every 60 min, unless someone posts after you in that time period. And you can only +/- one person at a time.

New:
Characters that only appear in the books have been removed. Characters from the Hobbit films have been added in.

Past winners:
Round 1 - Frodo
Round 2 - Haldir
Round 3 - Theodred
Round 4 - Faramir
Round 5 - Legolas
Round 6 - Legolas
Round 7 - Glorfindel
Round 8 - Fëanor
Round 9 - Gandalf
Round 10 - Éowyn
Round 11 - Treebeard



Aragorn (10)
Arwen (10)
Azog (10)
Balin (10)
Bard the Bowman (10)
Beorn (10)
Bifur (10)
Bilbo (10)
Bofur (10)
Bolg (10)
Bombur (10)
Boromir (10)
Denethor (10)
Dori (10)
Dwalin (10)
Elendil (10)
Elrond (10)
Éomer (10)
Éowyn (10)
Faramir (10)
Figwit (11) +
Fíli (10)
Frodo (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gamling (10)
Gandalf (10)
Gimli (10)
Glóin (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma Wormtongue (10)
Haldir (10)
Isildur (10)
Kíli (10)
Legolas (10)
Meriadoc 'Merry' Brandybuck (10)
Mouth of Sauron (10)
Nori (10)
Óin (10)
Ori (10)
Peregrin 'Pippin' Took (10)
Radagast (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Samwise Gamgee (10)
Saruman (10)
Sauron (10)
Smaug (10)
Tauriel (9) -
The Necromancer (10)
Théoden (10)
Théodred (10)
Thranduil 'Elvenking' (10)
Thorin II Oakenshield (10)
Treebeard (10)
Witch-King of Angmar (10)
Author:  Bellatrix [ May 8th, 2013, 9:06 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
Aragorn (10)
Arwen (10)
Azog (10)
Balin (10)
Bard the Bowman (10)
Beorn (10)
Bifur (10)
Bilbo (10)
Bofur (10)
Bolg (10)
Bombur (10)
Boromir (10)
Denethor (10)
Dori (10)
Dwalin (10)
Elendil (10)
Elrond (10)
Éomer (10)
Éowyn (10)
Faramir (10)
Figwit (11) +
Fíli (10)
Frodo (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gamling (10)
Gandalf (10)
Gimli (10)
Glóin (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma Wormtongue (10)
Haldir (10)
Isildur (10)
Kíli (10)
Legolas (10)
Meriadoc 'Merry' Brandybuck (10)
Mouth of Sauron (10)
Nori (10)
Óin (10)
Ori (10)
Peregrin 'Pippin' Took (10)
Radagast (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Samwise Gamgee (10)
Saruman (10)
Sauron (10)
Smaug (11) +
Tauriel (8) -
The Necromancer (10)
Théoden (10)
Théodred (10)
Thranduil 'Elvenking' (10)
Thorin II Oakenshield (10)
Treebeard (10)
Witch-King of Angmar (10
Author:  Seren [ May 8th, 2013, 9:08 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
Aragorn (10)
Arwen (10)
Azog (10)
Balin (10)
Bard the Bowman (10)
Beorn (10)
Bifur (10)
Bilbo (10)
Bofur (10)
Bolg (10)
Bombur (10)
Boromir (10)
Denethor (10)
Dori (10)
Dwalin (10)
Elendil (10)
Elrond (10)
Éomer (10)
Éowyn (10)
Faramir (10)
Figwit (12) +
Fíli (10)
Frodo (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gamling (10)
Gandalf (10)
Gimli (10)
Glóin (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma Wormtongue (10)
Haldir (10)
Isildur (10)
Kíli (10)
Legolas (10)
Meriadoc 'Merry' Brandybuck (10)
Mouth of Sauron (10)
Nori (10)
Óin (10)
Ori (10)
Peregrin 'Pippin' Took (10)
Radagast (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Samwise Gamgee (10)
Saruman (10)
Sauron (10)
Smaug (11)
Tauriel (7) -
The Necromancer (10)
Théoden (10)
Théodred (10)
Thranduil 'Elvenking' (10)
Thorin II Oakenshield (10)
Treebeard (10)
Witch-King of Angmar (10)
Author:  Bellatrix [ May 8th, 2013, 9:13 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
Aragorn (10)
Arwen (10)
Azog (10)
Balin (10)
Bard the Bowman (10)
Beorn (10)
Bifur (10)
Bilbo (10)
Bofur (10)
Bolg (10)
Bombur (10)
Boromir (10)
Denethor (10)
Dori (10)
Dwalin (10)
Elendil (10)
Elrond (10)
Éomer (10)
Éowyn (10)
Faramir (10)
Figwit (12)
Fíli (10)
Frodo (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gamling (10)
Gandalf (10)
Gimli (10)
Glóin (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma Wormtongue (10)
Haldir (10)
Isildur (10)
Kíli (10)
Legolas (10)
Meriadoc 'Merry' Brandybuck (10)
Mouth of Sauron (10)
Nori (10)
Óin (10)
Ori (10)
Peregrin 'Pippin' Took (10)
Radagast (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Samwise Gamgee (10)
Saruman (10)
Sauron (10)
Smaug (12) +
Tauriel (6) -
The Necromancer (10)
Théoden (10)
Théodred (10)
Thranduil 'Elvenking' (10)
Thorin II Oakenshield (10)
Treebeard (10)
Witch-King of Angmar (10)
Author:  Seren [ May 8th, 2013, 9:14 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
Aragorn (10)
Arwen (10)
Azog (10)
Balin (10)
Bard the Bowman (10)
Beorn (10)
Bifur (10)
Bilbo (10)
Bofur (10)
Bolg (10)
Bombur (10)
Boromir (10)
Denethor (10)
Dori (10)
Dwalin (10)
Elendil (10)
Elrond (10)
Éomer (10)
Éowyn (10)
Faramir (10)
Figwit (13) +
Fíli (10)
Frodo (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gamling (10)
Gandalf (10)
Gimli (10)
Glóin (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma Wormtongue (10)
Haldir (10)
Isildur (10)
Kíli (10)
Legolas (10)
Meriadoc 'Merry' Brandybuck (10)
Mouth of Sauron (10)
Nori (10)
Óin (10)
Ori (10)
Peregrin 'Pippin' Took (10)
Radagast (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Samwise Gamgee (10)
Saruman (10)
Sauron (10)
Smaug (12)
Tauriel (5) -
The Necromancer (10)
Théoden (10)
Théodred (10)
Thranduil 'Elvenking' (10)
Thorin II Oakenshield (10)
Treebeard (10)
Witch-King of Angmar (10)
Author:  Sírelindë [ May 8th, 2013, 9:16 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
Why remove characters who only appear in the books and instead include some who only appear in the movies?? I mean, characters like Tauriel and Figwit (sorry, love him too but still) aren't even Tolkien created so they can't be counted as canon :/ While characters like Beren and Lúthien, and Morgoth (without whom evil would not exist and there would be no story O.o) are very very important!!
Author:  Bellatrix [ May 8th, 2013, 9:20 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
Sírelindë wrote:
Why remove characters who only appear in the books and instead include some who only appear in the movies?? I mean, characters like Tauriel and Figwit (sorry, love him too but still) aren't even Tolkien created so they can't be counted as canon :/ While characters like Beren and Lúthien are very very important!!


I went by movie listings. The thing is, if we'd kept the original list as well as added all the characters mentioned in the Hobbit then the original list would be ridiculously long and it'd just take AGES to get anything done. So yeah, that's why.
Author:  Bellatrix [ May 8th, 2013, 9:21 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
Aragorn (10)
Arwen (10)
Azog (10)
Balin (10)
Bard the Bowman (10)
Beorn (10)
Bifur (10)
Bilbo (10)
Bofur (10)
Bolg (10)
Bombur (10)
Boromir (10)
Denethor (10)
Dori (10)
Dwalin (10)
Elendil (10)
Elrond (10)
Éomer (10)
Éowyn (10)
Faramir (10)
Figwit (13)
Fíli (10)
Frodo (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gamling (10)
Gandalf (10)
Gimli (10)
Glóin (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma Wormtongue (10)
Haldir (10)
Isildur (10)
Kíli (10)
Legolas (10)
Meriadoc 'Merry' Brandybuck (10)
Mouth of Sauron (10)
Nori (10)
Óin (10)
Ori (10)
Peregrin 'Pippin' Took (10)
Radagast (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Samwise Gamgee (10)
Saruman (10)
Sauron (10)
Smaug (13) +
Tauriel (4) -
The Necromancer (10)
Théoden (10)
Théodred (10)
Thranduil 'Elvenking' (10)
Thorin II Oakenshield (10)
Treebeard (10)
Witch-King of Angmar (10)
Author:  Sírelindë [ May 8th, 2013, 9:23 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
O_o Movie listings? But LotR is a book? And not to mention every character should be given equal chance, for fairness :)
Author:  Seren [ May 8th, 2013, 9:23 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
Aragorn (10)
Arwen (10)
Azog (10)
Balin (10)
Bard the Bowman (10)
Beorn (10)
Bifur (10)
Bilbo (10)
Bofur (10)
Bolg (10)
Bombur (10)
Boromir (10)
Denethor (10)
Dori (10)
Dwalin (10)
Elendil (10)
Elrond (10)
Éomer (10)
Éowyn (10)
Faramir (10)
Figwit (14) +
Fíli (10)
Frodo (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gamling (10)
Gandalf (10)
Gimli (10)
Glóin (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma Wormtongue (10)
Haldir (10)
Isildur (10)
Kíli (10)
Legolas (10)
Meriadoc 'Merry' Brandybuck (10)
Mouth of Sauron (10)
Nori (10)
Óin (10)
Ori (10)
Peregrin 'Pippin' Took (10)
Radagast (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Samwise Gamgee (10)
Saruman (10)
Sauron (10)
Smaug (13)
Tauriel (3) -
The Necromancer (10)
Théoden (10)
Théodred (10)
Thranduil 'Elvenking' (10)
Thorin II Oakenshield (10)
Treebeard (10)
Witch-King of Angmar (10)
Author:  Gersemi [ May 8th, 2013, 9:26 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
This game went more by the books in the beginning, rather than the movies. I agree with Sírelindë here. Removing characters from The Silmarillion doesn't seem right and adding a character like Tauriel seems wrong. She's not even a character created by Tolkien, but one instead made up by Peter for the film. I don't think non-canons fit here.
Author:  Bellatrix [ May 8th, 2013, 9:29 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
Sírelindë wrote:
O_o Movie listings? But LotR is a book? And not to mention every character should be given equal chance, for fairness :)


Lord of the Rings is also a movie trilogy. As is The Hobbit. ;)
They are given an equal chance? They all stared at ten. Like always.

Mrs. Haldir wrote:
This game went more by the books in the beginning, rather than the movies. I agree with Sírelindë here. Removing characters from The Silmarillion doesn't seem right and adding a character like Tauriel seems wrong. She's not even a character created by Tolkien, but one instead made up by Peter for the film. I don't think non-canons fit here.



Tauriel is like three posts from disappearing, surely that can't matter much at this point.

And it did go by the books, but there was also the rule only ONE post per hour no matter what. And the last round was the first time the previous winners were excluded. It seems the game is simply evolving a bit between rounds. Which genuinely just sparks it up a bit.
Author:  Bellatrix [ May 8th, 2013, 9:33 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
Aragorn (10)
Arwen (10)
Azog (10)
Balin (10)
Bard the Bowman (10)
Beorn (10)
Bifur (10)
Bilbo (10)
Bofur (10)
Bolg (10)
Bombur (10)
Boromir (10)
Denethor (10)
Dori (10)
Dwalin (10)
Elendil (10)
Elrond (10)
Éomer (10)
Éowyn (10)
Faramir (10)
Figwit (14)
Fíli (10)
Frodo (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gamling (10)
Gandalf (10)
Gimli (10)
Glóin (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma Wormtongue (10)
Haldir (10)
Isildur (10)
Kíli (10)
Legolas (10)
Meriadoc 'Merry' Brandybuck (10)
Mouth of Sauron (10)
Nori (10)
Óin (10)
Ori (10)
Peregrin 'Pippin' Took (10)
Radagast (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Samwise Gamgee (10)
Saruman (10)
Sauron (10)
Smaug (14) +
Tauriel (2) -
The Necromancer (10)
Théoden (10)
Théodred (10)
Thranduil 'Elvenking' (10)
Thorin II Oakenshield (10)
Treebeard (10)
Witch-King of Angmar (10)
Author:  Seren [ May 8th, 2013, 9:34 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
Tauriel is the only non-canon character in the list and she'll be voted out pretty soon if I have anything to do with it.

(OK, the name Figwit isn't canon, but the film character's real name, Lindir, is canon )


Aragorn (10)
Arwen (10)
Azog (10)
Balin (10)
Bard the Bowman (10)
Beorn (10)
Bifur (10)
Bilbo (10)
Bofur (10)
Bolg (10)
Bombur (10)
Boromir (10)
Denethor (10)
Dori (10)
Dwalin (10)
Elendil (10)
Elrond (10)
Éomer (10)
Éowyn (10)
Faramir (10)
Figwit/Lindir (15) +
Fíli (10)
Frodo (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gamling (10)
Gandalf (10)
Gimli (10)
Glóin (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma Wormtongue (10)
Haldir (10)
Isildur (10)
Kíli (10)
Legolas (10)
Meriadoc 'Merry' Brandybuck (10)
Mouth of Sauron (10)
Nori (10)
Óin (10)
Ori (10)
Peregrin 'Pippin' Took (10)
Radagast (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Samwise Gamgee (10)
Saruman (10)
Sauron (10)
Smaug (14)
Tauriel (1) -
The Necromancer (10)
Théoden (10)
Théodred (10)
Thranduil 'Elvenking' (10)
Thorin II Oakenshield (10)
Treebeard (10)
Witch-King of Angmar (10)
Author:  Bellatrix [ May 8th, 2013, 9:36 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
Aragorn (10)
Arwen (10)
Azog (10)
Balin (10)
Bard the Bowman (10)
Beorn (10)
Bifur (10)
Bilbo (10)
Bofur (10)
Bolg (10)
Bombur (10)
Boromir (10)
Denethor (10)
Dori (10)
Dwalin (10)
Elendil (10)
Elrond (10)
Éomer (10)
Éowyn (10)
Faramir (10)
Figwit/Lindir (15)
Fíli (10)
Frodo (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gamling (10)
Gandalf (10)
Gimli (10)
Glóin (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma Wormtongue (10)
Haldir (10)
Isildur (10)
Kíli (10)
Legolas (10)
Meriadoc 'Merry' Brandybuck (10)
Mouth of Sauron (10)
Nori (10)
Óin (10)
Ori (10)
Peregrin 'Pippin' Took (10)
Radagast (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Samwise Gamgee (10)
Saruman (10)
Sauron (10)
Smaug (15) +
Tauriel (0) -
The Necromancer (10)
Théoden (10)
Théodred (10)
Thranduil 'Elvenking' (10)
Thorin II Oakenshield (10)
Treebeard (10)
Witch-King of Angmar (10)


There Tauriel is gone, problem solved.
Author:  Sírelindë [ May 8th, 2013, 9:39 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best Character Elimination Round 12
By equal chance I mean people like Beren should at least have a place in the list.
I agree that the game evolving is a good thing but some things shouldn't be changed, like characters from the Silm should be included and film-only ones should not be, as they're not created by Tolkien.

@Seren Yes, but we all know Figwit and Lindir aren't the same person even though they're both portrayed by Bret McKenzie :P
Page 1 of 55 All times are UTC - 5 hours [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/