Arwen-Undomiel.com
http://arwen-undomiel.com/forum/

SC - Round 17 [X-mas Sig Set Awards] VOTING!
http://arwen-undomiel.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=29&t=13548		 Page 1 of 1
Author:  Kitoky [ January 11th, 2007, 5:39 pm ]
Post subject:  SC - Round 17 [X-mas Sig Set Awards] VOTING!
All right, I've gotta get this voting up before I have to start studying for exams.

For the SC - Round 17, participants have to make separate awards for the winners of Larael's Round 09 Holiday Sig Set Contest! :)

    1st - Johnny's Fan
    2nd - Gilraen Ringeril
    3rd - Antigone
    Honorable Mention - Elven Archer
    Host's Choice - Riniel Anariel


::: :::: :::: :::: :::: :::

The game plan!

For this voting, you're perfectly allowed to vote for EACH category. You're allowed to choose a 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and Hon. Mention for each 1st Place entrant awards, 2nd Place entrant awards, etc.

For example, if I were to judge from the 1st Place category it would be...

1st: Cheese
2nd: Milk
3rd: Yogurt
Honorable Mention: Eggs

That's only for the 1st Plast category though! For the 2nd Place category I'd pick...

1st: Yogurt
2nd: Milk
3rd: Eggs
Honorable Mention: Cheese

And so forth with each categories.

There are four categories.

1st Place Awards
2nd Place Awards
3rd Place Awards
Honorable Mention Awards
Host's Choice Awards

That means you get to vote 5 times!

:::: ::::: ::::: ::::: ::::

No comments are necessary since you guys are voting a lot, general comments for each person's set of awards are fine if you feel the need to be extremely kind! :D

No need to PM me. Just put your list in this thread because it's easier to vote a whole bunch times if you frequently see the entries. :)

Winners of Larael's contest, as like making awards, you cannot VOTE in your own category, but you are free to vote in any of the others. (However, if you entered this contest, you also can't vote; sorry guys! Chill out while someone else does the work for once.)

:::: :::: ::::: ::::: ::::

<center>1st PLACE AWARDS
Limwen - Villya ______________________________________________________ Nurrantiel
Image Image
Elven Archer _____________________________________________________Gilraen Ringeril
Image Image

2nd PLACE AWARDS
Limwen - Villya ______________________________________________________ Nurrantiel
Image Image
Elven Archer______________________________________________________Johnny's Fan
Image Image

3rd PLACE AWARDS
Limwen - Villya ______________________________________________________ Nurrantiel
Image Image
Elven Archer_____________________________________________________Gilraen Ringeril
Image Image
Johnny's Fan
Image

HONORABLE MENTION AWARDS
Limwen - Villya ______________________________________________________ Nurrantiel
Image Image
Gilraen Ringeril_____________________________________________________Johnny's Fan
Image Image

HOST'S CHOICE AWARDS
Limwen - Villya ______________________________________________________ Nurrantiel
Image Image
Elven Archer _____________________________________________________Gilraen Ringeril
Image Image
Johnny's Fan
Image
Author:  Bubble Black [ January 11th, 2007, 6:33 pm ]
Post subject: 
1st Place Awards

1st: Elven Archer
2nd: Limwen - Villya
3rd: Gilraen Ringeril
Honorable Mention: Nurrantiel

2nd Place Awards

1st: Limwen - Villya
2nd: Gilraen Ringeril
3rd: Elven Archer
Honorable Mention: Nurrantiel

3rd Place Awards

1st: Gilraen Ringeril
2nd: Johnny's Fan
3rd: Limwen - Villya
Honorable Mention: Elven Archer

Honorable Mention Awards

1st: Limwen - Villya
2nd: Gilraen Ringeril
3rd: Johnny's Fan
Honorable Mention: Nurrantiel

Host's Choice Awards

1st: Limwen - Villya
2nd: Elven Archer
3rd: Gilraen Ringeril
Honorable Mention: Johnny's Fan


Limwen - Villya: I am in love with your set - Very stylish and creative. Gorgeous colours and layout too.

Nurrantiel: Your set is great! They're all different whichh is wicked! :)

Elven Archer: So lovely! They're all simple and beautuful - Love 'em!

Gilraen Ringeril : Lovin' the font layout and colour - They're all gorgeous!

Johnny's Fan: I really like your set as well! The border and the way you plaved the text is wonderful!


Omg, aren't I nice? :P No, all absolutely beautiful entries - I love them all! :D
Author:  Beriadanwen [ January 11th, 2007, 9:40 pm ]
Post subject: 
(I stole Bubble's lovely voting format, hehe)

1st Place Awards

1st: Gilraen Ringeril
2nd: Elven Archer
3rd: Limwen-Villya
Honorable Mention: Nurrantiel

2nd Place Awards

1st: Limwen-Villya
2nd: Elven Archer
3rd: Johnny's Fan
Honorable Mention: Nurrantiel

3rd Place Awards

1st: Gilraen Ringeril
2nd: Johnny's Fan
3rd: Limwen - Villya
Honorable Mention: Elven Archer

Honorable Mention Awards (this round is unbelieveably hard to judge...I'm in love with all the entries...equally, I swear)

1st: Johnny's Fan
2nd: Limwen - Villya
3rd: Gilraen Ringeril
Honorable Mention: Nurrantiel

Host's Choice Awards

1st: Elven Archer
2nd: Gilraen Ringeril
3rd: Johnny's Fan
Honorable Mention: Limwen-Villya

I don't have time to do comments now...just the voting took me ages, but I definately will tomorrow :)

EDIT:

Comments

Limwen-Villya: I love how you went for consistency in all your awards, with that boxy thing. They all look really nice and well put together. Host's Choice and 1st Place were a bit too subdued for me, but I love love love 2nd place and HM :D

Nurrantiel: You used colour really well, they're very vibrant (save the last one, which is very cute in B&W). You're HM award is soooo cool. I love whatever textures and effects you used on the tree!!

Elven Archer: They're so pretty! 1st place is great, cause you kept it white and snowy, but still used lovely colours. And Host's Choice, well I'm a sucker for that picture, and I love how you made the ice stand out so much - it's seems as if it would be cold and wet if I touched it; great job!

Gilraen Ringeril: All so gorgeous!! 1st place is to die for, it looks so delicate and pretty. I love the vibrancy of 3rd place, it makes me think of a non-tacky, very fancy Christmas. Host's Choice, talk about red! It's excellent, fabulous work :D

Johnny's Fan: The usual tasteful graphics, that look so good right beside each other. Love the stars you put in all of them - it makes a great touch. HM award is my favorite - tis very shiny and pretty. They're all really really nicely done :yes:

Everybody: You all did such amazing work - it was really enjoyable voting and commenting on them. Every participant put a lot of work into them - it's an extra tough contest cause you've gotta have more than one entry. I would never have the patience. They're all awesome, voting wa s extremely difficult. Everyone should give themselves a pat on the back :)
Author:  Larael [ January 11th, 2007, 10:34 pm ]
Post subject: 
Am I aloud to vote? *steals voting format* Thank ye! :P

1st Place Awards

1st: Limwen - Villya
2nd: Elven Archer
3rd: Gilraen Ringeril
Honourable Mention: Nurrantiel

2nd Place Awards

1st: Johnny's Fan
2nd: Limwen - Villya
3rd: Elven Archer
Honourable Mention: Nurrantiel

3rd Place Awards

1st: Johnny's Fan
2nd: Limwen - Villya
3rd: Gilraen Ringeril
Honourable Mention: Elven Archer

Honourable Mention Awards

1st: Johnny's Fan
2nd: Gilraen Ringeril
3rd: Limwen - Villya
Honourable Mention: Nurrantiel

Host's Choice Awards

1st: Elven Archer
2nd: Limwen - Villya
3rd: Nurrantiel
Honourable Mention: Johnny's Fan

Comments:
Limwen - Villya: I love the flashy style you used! It was completely different compared to everyone elses and it really stuck in my mind. Good work!
Johnny's Fan: Lovely as usual! I couldn't have expected anything less from you. The colours weren't too bright and overwhelming, and you added a nice bit of embellishment too.
Gilraen Ringeril: Eye-poppingly stunning! Your colours were bright and bold which went nicely with the almost blended text.
Elven Archer: First off, let me say that you have improved soo much! All of your awards were crisp and fresh, and the colours were nice and clear. Splendidly done!
Nurrantiel: Your blending and usage of different textures made each award extremely unique. I love the usage of one certain colour scheme for each too.

:)
Author:  Riniel Anariel [ January 12th, 2007, 12:48 am ]
Post subject: 
1st PLACE AWARDS

1: Limwen - Villya
2: Gilraen Ringeril
3: Elven Archer
HM: Nurrantiel


2nd PLACE AWARDS

1: Limwen - Villya
2: Elven Archer
3: Johnny's Fan
HM: Nurrantiel


3rd PLACE AWARDS

1: Limwen - Villya
2: Elven Archer
3: Gilraen Ringeril
HM: Nurrantiel

Honorable Mention AWARDS

1: Limwen - Villya
2: Johnny's Fan
3: Gilraen Ringeril
HM: Nurrantiel


HOST'S CHOICE AWARDS

1: Limwen - Villya
2: Gilraen Ringeril
3: Elven Archer
HM: Johnny's Fan



Comments:

Limwen - Villya: I just loved all of them!! You had my vote with the shapes!! Amzing Color, texture and use of brushes and Light!!!
Amazing Job!!!

Elven Archer: I really loved the combinations of text that you used. The colors are gorgeous!! Beautifully done!

Gilraen Ringeril: I've always loved your use of color and contrast. You have done an amazing job on all of your awards!!! Great Job!!

Johnny's Fan: As always stunning beautiful graphics no matter what. Beautiful color, text and brushing!! Beautifully Done!!!!!!

Nurrantiel: You have done a beautiful job!!!!!!! I really like your coloring and texture. Some of the text is a little hard to see. Amazing Job!!

Everyone: You all did a wonderful job!! All of you have put a lot of time and effort into your art and it shows.
Author:  Kitoky [ January 15th, 2007, 12:11 pm ]
Post subject: 
Bumping. Only four people voted! Of course, I may not need all the votes but I haven't had the opportunity to tally it up yet. Chip in!
Author:  ~RinielAranel~ [ January 15th, 2007, 5:39 pm ]
Post subject: 
1st Place Awards

1st: Gilraen Ringeril
2nd: Limwen-Villya
3rd: Elven Archer
Honorable Mention: Nurrantiel

2nd Place Awards

1st: Limwen - Villya
2nd: Elven Archer
3rd: Johnny's Fan
Honorable Mention: Nurrantiel

3rd Place Awards

1st: Limwen - Villya
2nd: Gilraen Ringeril
3rd: Johnny's Fan
Honorable Mention: Elven Archer

Honorable Mention Awards

1st: Johnny's Fan
2nd: Limwen-Villya
3rd: Gilraen Ringeril
Honorable Mention: Nurrantiel

Host's Choice Awards

1st: Limwen - Villya
2nd: Elven Archer
3rd: Johnny's Fan
Honorable Mention: Gilraen Ringeril

The judging was incredibly hard...the different styles chosen for the awards were all done so very well. :)
Author:  Kitoky [ January 17th, 2007, 10:20 pm ]
Post subject: 
Closing voting. Standby for awards. Thanks to all those who participated! :)
Page 1 of 1 All times are UTC - 5 hours [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/