Hahahaha, Aerlinn. ^_^ I have to confess, I definitely don't have any daydreams about Maglor, no. Rofl, that's funny.

_________________

I have to admit to a little bit of Maglor squeeing in the past...and Maedhros is awesome, for having red hair. Among other things.
Also, I used to be kinda obsessed with Maeglin. Maybe I just have a thing for tragic elves...

_________________

and I'm still a dreamer, a believer
I've lost my faith in so many things but I still believe in You

Maaaaeeeeedhros. Oh, excuse me. Did someone say something? I'm afraid I missed it due to a certain red-haired elf... so tragic, so... fiery... Ahem.

I can't wait for that club to start.

_________________

Banner from Nellie

It does seem that Maedhros won out. Haha, now you've got me reading bunches of Silfics. O_o *repeats to self* I am not a fangirl... I am not a fangirl... I will never be a fangirl...

_________________

Banner from Nellie

*sighs* True, true... I suppose I'll just resign myself to my fate then, like Maedhros.

_________________

Banner from Nellie

Bwuahaha! That was brilliant. "Terribly, terribly sorry and all" Hahaha!!

Maedhros is just that way.

_________________

Banner from Nellie

Buahaha. I shall never declare whether or not I crush on any of them, Aerlinn. ^_^

...Terribly, terribly sorry and all. ^_^

_________________

Haha, we're all lusting over characters that don't even exist.

REVEAL YOUR LOVE, AERANDIR!

I never really cruched over Maglor, but I still harbor a definate love for Maedhros. He's just so epic!

I also like Turin. He's such a schmexy, angsty soul. Of course, if I met him in real life I'd probably smack him for being such a Debbie-Downer.

But I ADORE Beleg! He pwns every one, end of story. He's one of my only literary loves that isn't an angsty mess.

Buahaha. I really love....ALL OF THEM!!! O_O

Just kidding.

Did you think I would cave in so easily? Hah. You'll never find out who I truly love from The Silmarillion. ^_^ [evil laugh]

_________________

I will whap you with a copy of the Silm until you talk!

*whap* *whap* *whap*

Tell!

Though it is kinda impossible not to have at least a bit of a crush on most of the characters.

I actually have no such difficulty avoiding crushes on the male characters, Naur, no worries.

Tbh, I don't know that I have a 'crush' on any of the characters, except maybe Lúthien, and I think that any male in his right mind has a crush on her after reading The Silmarillion, so that's not much help.

_________________

... Well it's good to know that you're in your right mind.

_________________

Banner from Nellie

Lol, yes, it is. ^_^

_________________

*blinkblink*

Oh dear.
This is... scary. What about poor Maedhros?! XD He and Maglor are best combined with golden retrievers?!

_________________

Banner from Nellie

Haha, Aerlinn. I'm sure I didn't help at all with the fact that I'm a huuuuuge fan of Finrod and posted artwork of him?

It's kind of weird, but he reminds me of a golden retriever too. And Maedhros and Maglor are like...I have no idea.

_________________

I know this thread's a little old now and I hope no one minds me resurrecting it, it's just that I read the first post and HAD to comment. I feel I have found kindred souls

The first time I read The Sil, I grew really, really attached to Maedhros, so much so that I was almost crying when he finally perished. And when he was hanging on Thangorodrim and begging Fingon to kill him, I just wanted to give him the biggest cuddle ever, haha. I remember pausing for a moment, mid-chapter, and thinking to myself "Hold on a second, I have a crush on this elf!"

And even now, many years later, I still have a soft spot for him